RTUEE / EC / EEEYr 2020 · Sem 82020

Q2Protection of Power System

Question

16 marks

Q.2. (a) What are the HRC fuses? How these are different in construction from ordinary fuses? Also explain the applications of HRC fuses. [8]

(b) What do you understand by time multiplier setting and plug multiplier setting in an over current relay? Explain with the help of relay characteristics. Show why an IDMT characteristic is chosen in preference to simple inverse time characteristic. [8]

Answer

An HRC fuse is a fuse specifically designed to safely interrupt very high short-circuit fault currents (up to many tens of kiloamperes) without exploding, arcing over uncontrollably, or otherwise failing dangerously, achieving this high rupturing (breaking) capacity through a carefully engineered internal construction quite different from that of an ordinary, simple rewireable or cartridge-type fuse.

Construction Differences from Ordinary Fuses

An ordinary rewireable fuse consists simply of a thin fuse wire or element mounted in open air (or within a simple, loosely fitting fuse carrier) between two terminals; when a fault current melts the element, the resulting arc is exposed to the surrounding open air with no controlled means of extinguishing it, meaning the arc can persist, re-strike, or even cause the fuse carrier itself to fail explosively under high fault currents, and additionally the exact current-time characteristics of an ordinary fuse are poorly controlled and vary significantly from one physical fuse element to another. An HRC fuse, by contrast, encloses its fuse element (typically a specially shaped silver or copper element, often with one or more reduced-cross-section notches at intervals along its length to create multiple, controlled arcing points rather than a single arc location) within a sealed, non-combustible ceramic (or similarly robust) cartridge body, completely packed with a special quartz sand (or similar granular arc-quenching filler material) surrounding the element; when the element melts during a fault, the resulting arc is immediately surrounded by and interacts with this packed quartz filler, which absorbs and dissipates the arc energy extremely rapidly (partly by the filler melting locally around the arc to form a high-resistance fulgurite tube that constricts and helps extinguish the arc, and partly through the filler's excellent heat-absorbing and arc-quenching properties), enabling the HRC fuse to interrupt very high fault currents cleanly, safely, and with a precisely repeatable, factory-calibrated current-time characteristic, in sharp contrast to the poorly controlled behavior of an ordinary open-element fuse.

Applications of HRC Fuses

  • Protection of distribution transformers, where an HRC fuse mounted on the high-voltage side provides simple, low-cost, and highly reliable protection against transformer internal faults and, in many designs, against sustained external overloads, without requiring a more complex and costly circuit breaker and relay protection scheme.
  • Protection of motor circuits, particularly in combination with a thermal overload relay, where the HRC fuse provides fast, high-fault-current interruption capability that complements the thermal relay's role of protecting against sustained, lower-magnitude overload conditions that the fuse alone would respond to too slowly.
  • Back-up protection for low-voltage distribution feeders and industrial power distribution boards, providing a simple, maintenance-free means of clearing severe short-circuit faults quickly, often used as a back-up to a primary circuit breaker in case the breaker itself fails to clear the fault.
  • Protection of semiconductor power devices (specifically fast-acting, semiconductor-protection-grade HRC fuses, an even faster-acting variant of the standard HRC fuse construction) in power electronic converters, where the extremely short thermal withstand time of power semiconductor devices demands an extremely fast-clearing protective device.

Time Multiplier Setting and Plug Multiplier Setting

In an inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) electromechanical overcurrent relay, two independent adjustments are provided, allowing the relay's operating characteristic to be tailored to the specific coordination requirements of the point in the system where it is installed. The plug setting (plug setting multiplier, PSM) is an adjustment of the relay's effective current pickup value, traditionally implemented via a plug-bridge selecting different numbers of turns on the relay's operating coil (giving several discrete percentage settings of the CT secondary rated current, such as 50%, 75%, 100%, 125%, and so on), effectively setting the fault current level (relative to the relay's rated current) at which the relay begins to move toward tripping; the plug setting multiplier is then defined as the ratio of the actual fault current (referred to the relay's secondary side via the CT ratio) to the relay's plug-selected pickup current setting, PSM = (fault current / CT ratio) / plug setting current. The time multiplier setting (TMS) is a separate, independent adjustment (traditionally implemented by physically adjusting the initial travel distance the relay's moving disc or armature must travel before its contacts close) that uniformly scales the entire operating time for any given PSM value, without altering the underlying inverse-time shape of the characteristic curve itself; a TMS setting of 1.0 corresponds to the relay's full, standard operating time at any given PSM (as tabulated in the relay's published characteristic curve), while a TMS setting of, for example, 0.3 reduces the operating time to 30 percent of this standard, full-TMS value at the same PSM, allowing the protection engineer to shift the entire time-current curve up or down (in time) while keeping the same fundamental inverse-time shape and the same plug-setting-determined pickup threshold.

IDMT versus Simple Inverse Time Characteristic

A simple (purely) inverse time characteristic follows the relation operating time is inversely proportional to fault current (t is proportional to 1/I) over its entire operating range, meaning that as fault current increases without bound, the predicted operating time would continue to decrease without bound toward zero; in practice, however, no real relay mechanism can operate in literally zero time, and moreover, coordinating a purely inverse relay's operating time against relays elsewhere in the system becomes increasingly difficult at very high fault current multiples, since the extremely steep, ever-decreasing time-current slope at high currents makes precise time coordination between successive relays in a series protection scheme very sensitive to small variations in actual fault current magnitude. An inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) characteristic deliberately modifies the pure inverse relationship so that the operating time asymptotically approaches, but never falls below, a fixed minimum operating time value at very high fault current multiples (typically above roughly 10-20 times the relay's pickup setting), flattening out the characteristic curve at high fault currents into a nearly constant, definite minimum time rather than continuing to decrease toward zero. This IDMT modification is preferred over the simple inverse characteristic because it provides a much more practical and predictable basis for time-grading (coordinating) a series of relays along a radial or ring distribution feeder: since the operating time at high fault current multiples becomes nearly constant regardless of the precise fault current magnitude, the time margin required between successive relays for correct discrimination can be set to a smaller, more consistent value across the full range of possible fault currents, rather than needing to accommodate an ever-widening required time margin as fault current increases, as would be necessary with a purely inverse (unbounded) characteristic; this makes IDMT relays both easier to coordinate in practice and faster overall in clearing the most severe (highest current) faults, since the definite minimum time floor prevents unnecessarily long operating times at very high fault currents that a poorly-designed simple inverse characteristic extrapolated to very high currents might otherwise exhibit due to practical relay mechanism limitations.

Back to Paper