Q3Wireless Communication
Question
3. (a) What do you mean by PRMA? Discuss Aloha protocol with diagram. [8]
(b) Explain Rake receiver principle and working of the receiver. [8]
Answer
PRMA (Packet Reservation Multiple Access) and the ALOHA Protocol
PRMA (Packet Reservation Multiple Access) is a random-access protocol designed to efficiently combine the statistical multiplexing benefit of packet-based random access with the guaranteed, low-latency access needed for real-time traffic such as voice, by allowing successful contention-based access to a time slot to establish a 'reservation' of that same slot in subsequent frames for the duration of the ongoing talk-spurt. In PRMA, the frame is divided into slots, and any station with new information (a new talk-spurt) initially contends for an available (unreserved) slot using slotted-ALOHA-style random access with a permission probability; once a station's packet transmission in a given slot succeeds without collision, that same slot position becomes reserved for that station in all subsequent frames until its current talk-spurt ends, at which point the slot is released and becomes available for other stations to contend for again. This reservation mechanism means that only the initial packet of each talk-spurt suffers the delay and collision risk of the random-access phase, while all subsequent packets of the same talk-spurt are transmitted collision-free in their reserved slot, making PRMA well suited to bursty, talk-spurt-structured traffic such as speech, and forming an important conceptual bridge between pure random-access protocols and fixed TDMA slot assignment.
ALOHA is one of the earliest and simplest random-access multiple-access protocols, developed originally for the ALOHAnet packet radio network. In Pure ALOHA, any station with data to send transmits immediately, at any arbitrary time, without any coordination with other stations - if two or more stations happen to transmit packets whose durations overlap even partially in time, a collision occurs and all colliding packets are corrupted and must be retransmitted (typically after each involved station waits a random backoff interval, to reduce the probability of an immediate repeated collision). Because any part of one packet's transmission window can be corrupted by any part of another packet's transmission occurring up to one full packet duration before or after it, Pure ALOHA's vulnerable period for collision is two full packet durations, and its maximum theoretical channel throughput efficiency is only about 18.4% (1/(2e)) at the optimal offered traffic load, since it makes no attempt to coordinate or listen before transmitting.
Slotted ALOHA improves upon Pure ALOHA by dividing time into discrete, synchronized slots, with every station required to begin its transmission only at the start of a slot boundary (rather than at any arbitrary instant). This synchronization halves the vulnerable collision period to just one packet duration (since two packets can now only fully overlap or not overlap at all within a given slot, rather than partially overlapping across a much wider window), doubling the maximum theoretical throughput efficiency to about 36.8% (1/e) at the optimal offered load. Both variants of ALOHA remain fundamentally random-access, contention-based protocols (as opposed to the reservation-based or fixed-assignment protocols like TDMA), making them simple to implement and well suited to bursty, unpredictable traffic patterns, but with a throughput ceiling considerably below that achievable with more sophisticated protocols (including PRMA, discussed above, or full carrier-sense/collision-detection protocols) as offered traffic load increases toward and beyond the channel's saturation point.
Rake Receiver Principle and Working
A Rake receiver is a specialized receiver architecture used in DSSS/CDMA systems specifically to exploit, rather than merely tolerate, multipath propagation. Because a DSSS signal's PN spreading code has a sharply peaked autocorrelation function, the receiver can distinguish between multipath components arriving with different delays, provided those delays differ by at least roughly one chip period - the Rake receiver exploits this by employing multiple parallel correlator 'fingers,' each finger independently synchronized (time-aligned) to one specific resolvable multipath component's arrival delay, so that each finger despreads and coherently demodulates its own assigned multipath echo separately.
The outputs of all the individual Rake fingers are then combined (most commonly via maximal-ratio combining, MRC, where each finger's output is weighted in proportion to its own signal strength/SNR before summing) to produce a single, combined output signal with substantially improved signal-to-noise ratio compared to using only the single strongest multipath component alone - this is a direct application of multipath (time) diversity, converting what would otherwise be a destructive source of fading and intersymbol interference in a conventional single-path receiver into a beneficial diversity-combining gain. The name 'Rake' derives from the visual resemblance of the receiver's block diagram (multiple parallel finger branches converging into a single combiner) to a garden rake, and Rake receivers are a standard, essential component of virtually all practical DSSS and CDMA cellular receiver implementations (IS-95, CDMA2000, and WCDMA/UMTS all rely on Rake reception at the mobile and base station) specifically because the wide bandwidth of the spread signal inherently resolves multipath components that a narrowband receiver could not separately distinguish or exploit.
A further refinement beyond basic Slotted ALOHA that addresses some of its throughput limitations is Carrier Sense Multiple Access (CSMA), in which a station first listens to the shared channel before transmitting, and only proceeds to transmit if the channel is sensed to be idle, substantially reducing (though not entirely eliminating, due to the finite propagation delay between distant stations) the probability of collision compared to pure or slotted ALOHA's transmit-without-listening approach - CSMA and its collision-detection (CSMA/CD, as classically used in wired Ethernet) and collision-avoidance (CSMA/CA, as used in WiFi/802.11) variants represent a further evolutionary step in random-access protocol design beyond the ALOHA family discussed here, though PRMA's reservation-based approach remains particularly well suited to voice-oriented, talk-spurt-structured traffic in a way that plain carrier-sensing protocols do not directly address.
The Rake receiver's effectiveness is fundamentally limited by the number of resolvable multipath components the channel actually presents and the number of parallel fingers the receiver implementation provides - in a channel with very little multipath delay spread (for example, a clear line-of-sight rural environment), there may be few or no additional resolvable multipath components beyond the direct path, in which case a Rake receiver provides little to no combining benefit over a conventional single-path receiver, whereas in a rich multipath urban environment with substantial delay spread, a Rake receiver with a sufficient number of fingers can capture and combine several independently-fading multipath components, providing a substantial diversity gain that is one of the key practical advantages DSSS/CDMA systems hold over comparable-bandwidth narrowband systems operating in the same rich-multipath radio environment.