Q7Electrical Machine Design
Question
Q.7. What is the difference between brushless DC motor and switched reluctance motor?
Answer
A brushless DC motor uses permanent magnets on the rotor with electronically commutated stator windings (no brushes/commutator), while a switched reluctance motor has no rotor magnets/windings at all, relying purely on reluctance torque from a salient, ferromagnetic rotor.
A Brushless DC (BLDC) motor uses permanent magnets mounted on the rotor to establish the rotor's magnetic field, with the stator windings electronically commutated (switched) by power electronics based on rotor position feedback (from Hall-effect sensors or sensorless back-EMF sensing), producing torque through the interaction between the stator's rotating field and the permanent-magnet rotor field, similar in principle to a conventional DC motor but with the mechanical commutator/brush assembly replaced by electronic switching. A Switched Reluctance Motor (SRM), by contrast, has a rotor made purely of laminated ferromagnetic steel with salient poles and no magnets or windings at all, and produces torque purely through reluctance — the tendency of the rotor poles to align with the energized stator poles to minimize the magnetic circuit's reluctance — with stator phases sequentially energized by power electronics to pull the rotor poles into successive alignment, producing continuous rotation. The key difference is thus the rotor construction and torque production mechanism: BLDC relies on permanent-magnet field interaction (giving smoother torque and higher power density but requiring costly magnet material and more complex position sensing for commutation), while SRM relies purely on variable reluctance (giving a simpler, more robust, magnet-free and hence potentially cheaper rotor, but typically with more torque ripple and acoustic noise, requiring more sophisticated control algorithms to smooth out its inherently pulsating torque production).